Geography 226

Lab 5


Hypothesis Testing

Some people use statistics as a drunk uses a lamp post -

for support rather than illumination.

- Andrew Lang -


1. In hypothesis testing, it is important to state that one "cannot reject" the null hypothesis rather than state that the null hypothesis "can be accepted." Explain why this is the case.
 

2. You are analysing soil samples to test for lead concentrations in the old Expo 86 lands. According to BC Standards for Managing Contamination pdf file, (Level C), soil with an average lead (Pb) content greater than 1000 mg/kg is considered contaminated. Soil analysis is used to determine whether the soil requires remediation, based on Pb content.

a)     Summarize the decisions and errors associated with this hypothesis test in the table below. Label the Type I and Type II errors.

REALITY

DECISION


 


 

 


 


 

 


 


 

b)    List the outcomes of the decision. What are the consequences of error? Which consequence is the more serious?
 

c.)   Are the appropriate hypotheses directional or non-directional? Explain your rationale.

d)  Establish the appropriate null and alternate hypotheses to guard against making the serious error .


 

3. Two research questions are presented below. For each question:

  1. Establish the appropriate null and alternate hypotheses in text and symbols to answer the research question. Are the hypotheses directional or non-directional? Explain why.
     
  2. If your test results indicate you should reject H0, what will you conclude?
     
    Research 1: The total dissolved solids (TDS) in a local stream average 42 parts per million (ppm) over the course of a year. However, a recent sample shows that the mean TDS changed after portions of the watershed were logged. Is there a difference in the mean level of TDS in the stream before and after logging?
     
    Research 2: Residents have complained for many years about the poor air quality surrounding a local pulp mill. The city hires a consultant to sample the airborne particulate levels within 5 km of the mill and more than 5 km from the mill. Are particulate levels higher near the mill?

Marking Guide (Lab Total = 20)

Question

Mark

 

Question

Mark

Q1

 

1

Q3

R1

4

 

 

R2

4

Q2

a

4

   

b

2

   

c

1

   

d

4